According to the IRS rules, an employee is any worker whose work is controlled by the employer. In other words, the employer determines the scope of work, how the work is to be done, and provides the tools required for the job. On the other hand, an independent contractor is a worker who determines how to work, provides his or her own tools for the job, and controls the work at hand. However, in some instances, determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor is not so clear in black and white, but in a gray area. However, some employers categorize obvious employees as independent workers so as to avoid paying payroll taxes. If an employer is found to have categorized employees as independent contractors, he or she will be liable to heavy penalties if caught by the IRS and the assessment taxes may well hit very high figures. For employers who find themselves in such a situation, there is still a way that they can avoid being implicated for the wrong-doing. They can take advantage of the tax relief provision under Section 530.
Tax Relief Provision under Section 530
Under this tax relief law, an employer can escape the IRS’s reprimand even after categorizing an employee as an independent contractor if he or she can prove all of the following:
- That the person was never treated as employee by the employer throughout their relationship
- That the employee is treated in the same manner as an independent contractor
- That all tax records for the person in question indicates that he or she is an independent contractor – records include From 1099 and tax returns.
- That the employer was reasonable when categorizing the person in question as staff. There are three things that can show that the employer was reasonable:
- If the IRS or a tax court ruled that a person in a similar position was an independent contractor
- If past IRS audits raised no problem with the person being an independent staff member
- If it is an old practice in the industry for people in similar positions to be treated as independent contractors
Timing of the Section 530 Safe Harbor
For an employer to satisfactorily win a case under Section 530, they must show that they had considered all of the four above points before making the decision to determine an otherwise employee, as an independent contractor. Therefore, the employer must prove that since taking up the services of the person in question, the employer has never employed any person in a same or similar position and that he or she has never treated an employee in the same manner as the person in question. However, the tricky part to prove is usually the fourth rule of the Section 530 relief. Employers who find themselves in this situation must find court rulings that determined that a person in a similar position was deemed an independent contractor. Such ruling must have happened before the time the employer engaged the person in question.
Case in Point – Peno Trucking
In the case of Peno Trucking vs. the IRS Commissioner, Peno Trucking sort to avoid an IRS tax charge for a worker that they had categorized as an independent worker but the IRS considered to be an employee. The tax court ruled that the employer failed to provide any relevant judicial precedent and therefore ruled that the trucking company was liable to pay the due taxes. In a reversal of the ruling previously made by the tax court, the court ruled that Peno Trucking could have used an Ohio ruling (that happened prior to the trucking company hiring the worker) to categorize the worker as an independent contractor. The trucking company was thus released of any related taxes due.











